I've officially found the holy grail of thrift shops and it's located in a huge, three-story Victorian mansion attached to a Catholic grade school and a church. It's like the craziest estate sale you've ever been to... but open year round! The people are super friendly, the prices are ridiculous, and they have everything: furniture, clothes, shoes, books, home goods. It was such a trip to visit and I'm totally going back.
St. Agnes Thrift Shop
Atlantic Highlands, NJ